It looks like, from the 1914--1916 directories, that we can eliminate the third possibility. A. Hovich and Company is listed as ship smith. The business address is an area that seems to have housed repair works from the pictures I've found.
>I have seen some incredable work that I would have bet money was not hand made that was.
I've seen some, too. Jay Sharp, for example. John Suttle made some of his own, and some are work expedient, while others are finely finished.
Antone may have bought it, or he might have made it. There are no other marks except A Hovich & Co stamped into the top and bottom, by the eye. It's a mystery until I can find more information. Thinking of the time and the place, I think it likely that Hovich was an immigrant, and had learned his trade in Europe, and had learned to make his own tools. My first smithing teacher learned his trade from his father and his German grandfather, and making his tools was part of his apprenticeship.
Either way, though, this hammer was stamped by him, sometime between 1914 and 1916, when the company disappears. There's a certain romance in that. And, of course, any good hammer is worth a lot more than $5. I can hardly wait to handle it up!