Sorry, I was off thread for quite awhile.
I think patina is good to a point, I even add it, although sparingly, to many of my creations (except glass.) It brings out highlites and can help define a piece.
It wouldn't improve that plane any, though. I think it looks beautiful polished. And it is hard to get silver perfect on a flat plane on such a small scale, especially cast, without sophisticated vacuum machinery. Silver is, after all, the most highly reflective surface there is
I don't personally care for wire brushing and other methods of patina removal where material is removed. I think brass can look great when brown. And for those tools that have been varnished after being aggressively cleaned, its not my thing. I don't care for much of the obvious aging, either. Faux aged and painted highlites to give the appearance of age is usually to obvious.
So I am on the fence. When is enough cleaning enough? Usually I proceed slowly, using cleaning oils on wood and weak acids on metal. While cleaning a level recently the brass plate was hard to clean evenly around the screws. I had to unscrew the plate and do the screw heads seperately. Took some time. But, I am not in this to resell. For me, it is done when it looks right. Sometimes I have to put something aside for a bit until I feel good about going forward. But, I always eventually like the result.
And that result, for me, is that I like it to look aged, but like it was very well cared for and has never had damaging use or abuse.