The grease should be sticky and jelly like, if you can stand a pencil up in it, it's old and cooked ;P
What scott said on lithium, it is what they supply for most of the newer tools, the very old stuff used somewhat different grease, they were trying to keep it from getting flung off the gears in a tool that gets dropped, vibrated, shaken, cooked etc....
make sure you clean the metal with something to get every last little bit of old grease off it tho, mixing two different kinds of grease can cause the grease to chemically react, turning into cement, or oil with sludge n it ;P
PS: Stay away from anything that says 'biodegradable', you don't want the grease in your saw biodegrading.....(it is for boat trailors, so it won't pollute the ocean)
PPS: Do *not* use brake cleaner, it will instantly dissolve the motor winding insulation.