Wow! I was just getting ready to post my newly acquired Garland # 5 soft face hammer, when I run across this post!!
Garland is made in SACO, Maine. Weighs 6 pounds!
I found it w/o the inserts, went on line and found the water buffalo hide replacements, and bought them.
Over 40 dollars for one set of two. Easy to install with the huge nut that tightens the 2 parts together.
As instructed by the mfr, I put neats foot oil on the new inserts.
This is a HUGE, heavy hammer. Wonder what it was used for?